Movie poster for "Paper Tiger"

Paper Tiger

Like

Crime, Thriller

Director: James Gray

Release Date: November 20, 2026

Where to Watch

Set in Queens, New York, in 1986, “Paper Tiger” (2026) follows the Pearl family as they hit a wall in the form of a business opportunity that ends up being more trouble than its worth. How long will it take before they realize that they had everything and instead of savoring it, wanting more was a big mistake? Miles Teller, Adam Driver and Scarlett Johansson helm writer and director James Gray’s latest film. Driver plays Gary as the self-styled mover and shaker who takes care of his family man brother, Irwin (Teller), and loves to show off in front of Irwin’s wife, Hester (Johansson), and his nephews, Ben (Roman Engel) and Scott (Gavin Goudey). Well-intentioned Gary seeks to make their father’s dream come true and start a consulting business for recent Russian immigrants cleaning up the Gowanus Canal, but apparently Irwin has zero sense and sparks the ire of their new business associates, which threatens to ruin everything. If you enjoy genre films that remind you of better films with a mostly male cast, then this movie is for you, but everyone else may just spend the entire time racking their brains to pinpoint which films it feels like. With performances ranging from all-time best to over acting, Gray’s film obviously is trying to convey something important, but it gets lost in the chaos.

Good news or bad news first? My pick: bad news. After watching “Paper Tiger,” I did a little deep dive to find out which scenes were important to Gray and confirmed my gut. If the story feels scattered, it is because Gray is trying to tie together pivotal dramatic moments in his life without taking an autofiction route. While those scenes are powerful, because those characters, the children, are not consistently center stage, he is not tackling these moments head on and winds up inadvertently pulling a M. Night Shyamalan with Gary that feels obligatory, not revelational. Engel and Goudey have one of the more important scenes, but their characters otherwise do not stand out. Their roles simply feel like the adult characters’ extensions, not three-dimensional characters who are the center of their own movie. Gray squeezes a domestic drama into a crime genre to elevate stakes that are already high thus losing everything in the noise. I hope he tries again and faces it more head on. Keep it simple and focus on the real issue instead of smothering it in crime drama beats. While Gray may be consciously subverting the mafia genre to show it from the relatively innocent perspective, the ride is predictable. With a register always at a ten, it does nothing to elicit real emotion in the audience. There is a subtle theme about the pollution in the Gowanus, Hester’s story arc and the corruption in the New York Police Department, which somehow Gray depicts Gary as simultaneously clean and just as shady. Even without the business scheme, this family feels doomed.

I have always thought that Driver is overrated, but he is at his best when acting with children and animals, which usually derails an average actor. Also, I am on a personal mission to help those attracted to men to distinguish between a man being tall from a handsome man. They are not the same thing, but people still have the hots for Pete Davidson and Driver. I’m fighting a losing battle, but I’m the first one to acknowledge that if you put Driver in a nice suit, keep the camera far away and start rolling, he strikes an impressive silhouette, which is the point of “House of Gucci” (2021). “Paper Tiger” agrees because they hired the same tailor, Leonard Logsdail, to make Driver’s suits in this one. Here, Driver does an accent that is painful to listen to but otherwise does a good job though the character does not feel as if it is emerging deep from his bones. He succeeds on taking his character on a journey of realization about his place in the world, and he ends on a nice note with some of Gray’s outstanding directorial work in a curtain call that is the film’s zenith, but it is too little, too late.

Teller and Johansson have great chemistry, and because they establish the couple’s dynamic within seconds on screen without words, it allows them a huge amount of freedom when the plot unfolds to ridiculous levels because they ground it and pull it together. It starts in a typical scene with Hester telling their sons that they must do something, and Irwin acts as the enforcer. When they are out of their boys’ earshot, Irwin asks if he must go, and Hester just laughs. The dialogue is not notable, but the acting is. They occupy their characters in such an authentic way that in that moment, her reaction reveals that she knows it is a joke, he is reliable, and they love each other. When they start hitting speed bumps and being isolated from each other, it feels like a real cataclysm. A lot of movies do not spend enough time establishing a group as a solid unit before tearing them apart, but with actors as good as Teller and Johansson, the writer can take a break.

Teller is a consistent affable actor who is terrific at becoming his character and being innately charming, which is a good thing because Irwin is such an annoying, dumb ass that without Teller, moviegoers would root against his character. If you think that his character is going to be a whistleblower type fighting a David Goliath fight, let me spare you that expectation.  “Paper Tiger” is not that kind of movie. Gray plays a bit of bait and switch framing Irwin as the protagonist, but he may be the least important character in the entire story. Teller never betrays that information and is every bit the leading man, but even Gray’s creative choice shortchanges his story. Gray is hiding behind the everyman. There is a play on shadows that Teller and Gray nail. The visual atmosphere in this movie is perfect.

Johansson is almost in an entirely different movie from everyone else, and Gray’s curtain call for Hester is outstanding. If Gray faced the story head on, Hester still would not be the main character, but Johansson kind of kidnaps the entire movie at every chance that she gets, and Gray wisely seems happy to oblige since she is doing his work for him. A baby born yesterday could predict her character’s trajectory, and Johansson imbues her character with the most first-time experience emotion ever. While the hair and accent are wearing her, Johansson commits to the interiority of the role that makes Hester feel like an individual person, not some hack character broadly written like everyone else. Gray pulls punches with Hester because the first act reflects that she wants a better lifestyle, and Irwin feels the burden, but during their disagreement, he never lashes out at her as a reason that he wants more, which may indicate more about Irwin’s character than Hester, but Hester also never has a moment of self-condemnation.

For the longest time, Steven Spielberg and Pedro Almodovar’s movies repeatedly explored the same themes, but they did not have the strength to directly tackle them. “Paper Tiger” feels like that kind of movie, and while most guys will eat this up with a spoon because it is like other classics, Gray cheats himself of true greatness and lacked the discipline and fortitude to consistently do his own thing. This is not a movie that only he could do, but it does signal that he is on the right track. Courage, Gray! What an eye, but that quill needs sharpening.

Stay In The Know

Join my mailing list to get updates about recent reviews, upcoming speaking engagements, and film news.